Every manager faces a moment they dread, the underperformance chat, the behaviour conversation, the awkward “we need to talk.”
Handled badly, these moments can fracture trust.
Handled well, they become the turning points where growth happens.
Why tough conversations feel so hard
It’s not the words — it’s the emotion.
We worry about being too harsh, too soft, or simply saying the wrong thing. Many managers end up delaying the talk until frustration builds, which almost guarantees defensiveness.
The truth is, difficult conversations are where management earns its name.
The power of preparation
Start with clarity. Ask yourself three things before any tough conversation:
- What’s the behaviour or issue I need to address – specifically?
- What impact is it having?
- What outcome do I want?
Then anchor the discussion in empathy:
“I want to talk about something important because I care about your success.”
It lowers defences instantly.
Use a simple framework
The AID model is one of the most effective:
- Action: Describe what happened factually.
- Impact: Explain how it affects the team or results.
- Desired Outcome: Agree on what good looks like.
This keeps the tone constructive rather than personal.
Inside the Alpha Lupa Advantage Academy, we help managers practise these conversations safely because confidence comes from rehearsal, not theory.
The LUPA Method approach
- Learn what triggers defensiveness in yourself and others.
- Understand your default conflict style.
- Plan your structure, tone, and environment.
- Act with empathy and consistency, and always follow up.
What happens when you get it right
Difficult conversations become easier, trust deepens, and performance improves. People want feedback, they just don’t want fear attached to it.
👉 Explore the Academy today and turn confrontation into collaboration.
Stay sharp with AlphaThinking
Subscribe to AlphaThinking for more scripts, conversation frameworks, and real stories from managers like you.
Each edition brings you bite-sized leadership ideas straight to your inbox.
✨ Sign up to AlphaThinking and learn how to lead the conversations that matter most.
Alpha Lupa Insight
Courageous communication is the hallmark of great management. When you replace avoidance with clarity, you turn tension into trust.
